Print page Send link

Case Law of the European Court of Human Rights

20 Jun 2015

On 16 June 2015 the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights has passed its ruling in the Delfi AS v Estonia case. Delfi is one of the largest news portals in Estonia. The case involved Delfi publishing an article, which generated a number of comments by its readers, some of which included direct threats against an individual. The individual asked Delfi to remove such comments and pay damages. Delfi complied with removing the comments, although refused to reimburse damages claiming that Delfi is a neutral intermediary and therefore immune from liability under the e-Commerce Directive. 

The Court has ruled that Delfi went beyond that of a passive, purely technical service provider, in particular due to the fact that Delfi has exercised a substantial degree of control over the comments published on its portal and invited the users to post comments, having also an economic interest. The Court eventually ruled that where third-party user comments are in the form of hate speech and direct threats to the physical integrity of individuals, as understood in the Court’s case-law, the Court considers that the rights and interests of others and of society as a whole may entitle Contracting States to impose liability on Internet news portals, without contravening Article 10 of the Convention, if they fail to take measures to remove clearly unlawful comments without delay, even without notice from the alleged victim or from third parties. 

The judgment can be found here

Back to the news list

Highlights

Litigation

13 Nov 2023

The law firm has successfully represented the client at the Klaipėda Regional Court in a case where damages were awarded to the client in relation to the annulment of an Option Agreement.

Protection of creditors' rights in the downfall of a Lithuanian fintech company

11 Nov 2023

As one of the Lithuanian players of the fintech sector undergoes bankruptcy proceedings, the law firm representing creditors closely monitors the situation at UAB "PAYRNET" to secure their rights and recoup losses

Disputes resolution

21 Jun 2023

Successful representation at the Supreme Court of Lithuania on recognition and enforcement of Russian court rulings in Lithuania

International recognition - Dispute resolution

12 Apr 2023

The law firm Šulija Partners Law Firm Vilnius has been listed as one the leading law firms Dispute Resolutions practice area

More news...

Šulija Partners Law Firm Vilnius, registered office Jogailos street 11, Vilnius, LT-01116, Lithuania, fax +370 52051926, e-mail: info@SulijaPartners.com

Contact details | Sitemap | Know your customer | Privacy policy | Feedback | Links | Terms and Conditions | Attorney advertising | Copyright Back to the top